When the former defender took over as the club's boss in the winter, there was a severe lack of time to get acclimated. An intense run of games meant a phased integration to his squad was simply not feasible.
Spanish media warned of the challenges he would encounter, particularly overseeing a dressing room packed with some of football's biggest personalities.
However forging solid bonds with the squad members was not a concern for the ex- Liverpool defender.
"It's not something that troubles me much," the coach said at his introductory news conference.
Two months later, he states those relationships are developing further and the outcomes on the pitch are coming as a result.
Establishing Connections
During the spring, Arbeloa led his team to wins against clubs managed by elite coaches: the Portuguese manager's Benfica, the Catalan's City and Diego Simeone's Atletico Madrid.
Real Madrid are still a quartet of points behind the Spanish league leaders their arch-rivals, with a potentially title-deciding Clasico in the spring, while their Champions League journey proceeds with a last-eight encounter against Bayern Munich.
Real's performances are on the up and the chemistry between the manager and players are building.
"I am becoming to know the individuals more and more," said the head coach after his team's 3-2 success against rivals Atletico last week.
"I came in at a moment when I almost had no time to work with the squad, to see where they felt comfortable, and to observe how they mixed with one another."
He acknowledged the circumstances of his appointment presented new challenges.
"For me, it's difficult to come in the middle of the campaign and observe how the squad functions, and that is precisely what has changed over these two months," he went on.
"At present I know my players as individuals and footballers, where I can extract the peak display from them, and where I can tweak things."
Plaudits for Vinicius
A key individual thriving under Arbeloa is Vinicius Jr.
He has started 16 of Arbeloa's 17 matches in charge, with his goal return also improving significantly - he has netted 11 times under the current boss, as opposed to registering just six in 27 appearances under his predecessor.
Arbeloa has concentrated on restoring the attacker's self-belief, pushing him to play with freedom and express himself rather than restricting him tactically.
"I'm lucky to have Vinicius, he's adored by the entire fanbase. We want to see the Vinicius who has fun on the pitch, who smiles, who celebrates… that's the Vini I want to see," he stated in his initial news conference as manager.
This method stands in opposition to reports of tension under Alonso, with the forward being heard to say "I'm going to leave this team" after being substituted in October's Clasico.
The new boss has publicly supported him, emphasizing he is fully backed by the coaching staff and the entire squad.
"He's one of the deadliest footballers, if not the most dangerous, in the world today and he represents what a this club's player is," stated Arbeloa.
Vinicius placed negotiations about his long-term prospects in abeyance last summer but, recently, he made his commitment to the club.
"I am solely thinking about Real Madrid and staying there for a long time," he told the press before his national team's friendly match with the French team.
Valverde Finds Form Once More
The Uruguayan midfielder's performances has also skyrocketed since the new coach took over.
Under the previous coach, he managed three goals and seven goal contributions from 31 games.
Ever since Arbeloa's appointment, he has started all 17 of his games, finding the net seven times and registering five assists.
A key factor has been a positional shift to his natural place in midfield.
Throughout Alonso's spell, Valverde at times had difficulty trying to nail down a starting spot in his natural role, being deployed in unfamiliar roles such as full-back.
While the choice was in part because of injuries to teammates, Valverde's displeasure was clear. "I wasn't born to be a defender," he stated.
But now, restored to his favored role, the midfielder is excelling.
He has netted six goals in just a month, featuring a three-goal haul against City and a winning goal in a 3–2 triumph over their city rivals.
Youth Integration, Greater Possibilities?
The manager's background as boss of Real Madrid's reserve team has made blending youth prospects into the first team feel effortless, so it was logical to anticipate him to give up-and-coming players minutes.
That happened most notably when the team played their opponents earlier this month and Arbeloa handed playing time to six Castilla graduates.
One player, in particular, has swiftly established himself as one of Arbeloa's most talented disciples.
At just 18 years of age and 226 days old, he became the most youthful player in the team's history to begin a match twice in the Champions League latter stages, breaking Vinicius' record by 10 days.
Asked what it meant to see several homegrown players on the pitch, Arbeloa couldn't mask his pride.
"I think I can be content after a evening like tonight," he stated.
"I was recently talking to two of them, who were the initial youngsters I managed when they were 13 or 14, and to be able to give them the chance to play at the Bernabeu is a lifelong dream realized for me."
Although the coach might be well-acquainted with the Castilla players, he concedes fitness setbacks have curtailed his exposure